News + Opinion » Opinion

A complex lesson

To the editor,

Re: "Military school," Dec. 20: As one of the King's journalism students on the Pearson Peacekeeping Centre-sponsored trip to Turkey, I found Bruce Wark's column on the subject unfair. Far from unscrupulously providing a service to the Turkish army in exchange for cold, hard cash, the students participated in a reciprocal relationship that benefited both sides and was profoundly educational.

The notion that we went to Istanbul to give tips to NATO on spinning the media originates in Mr. Wark's imagination. The purpose of our trip was not "to hone PR skills"—it was to pressure officers to be more accountable and open to us. This is why, in the course of the simulation, we demanded press conferences, refused to accept opaque answers and complained bitterly in our published work when we felt fair standards of transparency were not being met.

If the only possible relationship between the media and the military is one of antagonism, as Mr. Wark suggests, then we accomplished this minimum. Fortunately, we also took away more complex lessons, among them that in conflict situations (real or well-simulated) moral distinctions shift easily, and to describe any one side as completely good or completely bad is unhelpful.

By Richard Norman

Add a comment

Remember, it's entirely possible to disagree without spiralling into a thread of negativity and personal attacks. We have the right to remove (and you have the right to report) any comments that go against our policy.

xxx - Deprecated in favor of GTM, above.