Gold Winner The Bicycle Thief

Silver Winner La Frasca Cibi + Vini

Bronze Winner Vinnie’s Pasta Bar (now closed)

“It’s like coming into our living room.” That’s how John Michael Brewer describes the vibe of The Bicycle Thief, a multi-winner (four to be exact) in this year’s readers’ survey. “It’s funny that the award is fine dining, we consider ourselves pretty casual.” Regardless, readers agree that a night, or afternoon and this Bertossi Group super star is always fine—whether they’re seated at the Fire & Ice bar, sunning on the patio or piling the gold-winning Best Pasta into their mouthes and washing it down with a little Chianti.