Nothing says respectability like 68 years in the business, but nothing says fun like a ‘50s diner-style eatery. The Chickenburger walks the line with three pillars of success, says general manager Colin MacDonald. “Experience, a fun time and a friendly atmosphere.” Oh, and the food. “It’s a unique product. It’s real, local food. Hamburger comes from the valley and the chicken is made fresh daily.” And don’t forget the award-winning milkshakes. 1531 Bedford Highway, 835-6565

First runner up: Il Mercato Ristorante

Second runner up: Cellar Bar & Grill