Music » Reviews

Kathleen Edwards

Asking for Flowers

by

comment


Kathleen Edwards
Asking for Flowers
(Maple)
On her 2002 debut, Failer, Kathleen Edwards introduced herself as a mouthy boozehound with an alt-country bent. On Back to Me, she reflected on a life changed by success. Asking for Flowers, co-produced by the artist and Jim Scott (Tom Petty), sounds bigger and smaller than both. Bookended by epics “Buffalo” and “Goodnight, California,” the songs start so intimately---
you hear piano pedals being stepped 
on---that their lush builds are engrossing surprises. There’s some pure country (“The Cheapest Key,” “Run”) and a handful of songs that weave in larger issues---a first. Edwards, a vocal Toronto hater, moved from the city to Hamilton after a personal incident with gun violence, which resonates more universally in the form of “Alicia Ross” and “Oh Canada.” The former takes the POV of the Markham woman murdered by her neighbour, an understated song in which Edwards asks Ross’s mother, “Was your darkest day as dark as this one?” The latter references the Boxing Day 2005 shooting of Jane Creba, ultimately condemning the whole city: “There are no headlines when a black girl dies/It’s not the lack of a sense, it’s called ambivalence.” On the title track she sings, “Don’t tell me you’re too tired/10 years I’ve been working nights.” That decade has produced some stellar songs. If Edwards grows at her current rate, she’ll be an artist for the ages.
Tara Thorne

Add a comment

Remember, it's entirely possible to disagree without spiralling into a thread of negativity and personal attacks. We have the right to remove (and you have the right to report) any comments that go against our policy.