Arts + Culture » Film + TV

Kitschy Snow Flower and the Secret Fan

Chinese historical drama stilted, stiff and unintentionally funny


In present day Shanghai, Nina (Bingbing Li) visits her comatose laotong (sworn sister) Sophia (Gianna Jun) in hospital. She reads Sophia’s unpublished manuscript, a parallel story of two other laotong, Snow Flower and Lily (Jun and Li) living in 1820s Hunan Province. The elaborate costumes are the most compelling part of the movie, which has a heavy dose of bound feet, sisterly love and womanly fate (babies, obedience). Stilted dialogue prevents character development, summarizing major plot twists with utilitarian language reminiscent of a soap opera. Wayne Wang’s melodramatic film adaptation is unintentionally funny---even with (or maybe because of) a multitude of writers, Lisa See’s novel turns into a weak screenplay. A bizarre mix of traditional Chinese culture with Hollywood kitsch---an attempt to cater to an American audience, I assume---only makes this worse (especially Hugh Jackman’s role as a prancing nightclub owner).

Related Film

Snow Flower and the Secret Fan

Official Site:

Director: Wayne Wang

Writer: Angela Workman

Cast: Bingbing Li, Gianna Jun, Vivian Wu, Hugh Jackman, Archie Kao, Wu Jiang and Angela Evans

Add a comment

Remember, it's entirely possible to disagree without spiralling into a thread of negativity and personal attacks. We have the right to remove (and you have the right to report) any comments that go against our policy.