Dee Dee’s Ice Cream’s vanilla ice cream, Helen B’s Preserves’ strawberry rhubarb jam and Smith's Bakery ginger cookies
Humani-T Cafe’s dark chocolate gelato, 24 Carrots Bakery’s chocolate-dipped shortbread and coconut flakes
Common Confections’ salted caramel dairy-free frozen dessert, LF Bakery’s milk bun and toasted sesame seeds
Scanway Catering & Pastry’s croissant dough doughnut with vanilla glaze and sprinkles and Pete’s Fine Foods’ piña colada gelato
Tips for making ice cream sandwiches1. Ice cream, gelato or frozen dessert should be in your home freezer for five to six hours after its trip from place of purchase, before assembling the sandwiches, to avoid having ice cream soup on your hands.
2. Buy your frozen dessert in a paper pint, if possible, so that pucks of ice cream can be cut for sandwiches by sawing right through the pint with a bread knife, which means less handling and less melting.
4. Once the sandwich is assembled, place in freezer immediately for three to four hours before eating—that way it will freeze again. You can wrap the sandwiches individually in wax paper or parchment, or place on a baking sheet in the freezer for more immediate eating.
5. From one pint of frozen dessert, four pucks can usually be cut,
which requires eight pieces for the sandwich sides.